TheMagic5 Swimming Goggles: A Comprehensive Review (2024)

TheMagic5 swimming goggles reviewed

In a market flooded with one-size-fits-most options, TheMagic5 swimming goggles promise a custom fit and professional-grade performance. They are touted for their comfort and clarity for every face type and swimming ability due to their custom made production process.

We had to find out for ourselves if these goggles are everything people have been saying. Do The Magic 5’s personalized approach provides a noticeable advantage in the water? I wanted to know.

Read on to see what we discovered, and you can decide if they’re a wise investment for your swim sessions.


  • TheMagic5 swimming goggles offer a customized fit using 3D printing technology based on a detailed face scan, aiming to provide comfort without the tight suction of traditional goggles.
  • Every pair of TheMagic5 goggles is tailored to the wearer and designed to enhance performance with features like an anti-fog treatment and a promise of leak-free swimming. They have an aggressive fit with the goggles fitting in the eye socket.
  • While TheMagic5 goggles are more expensive than typical swimming goggles, their custom fit and comfort might justify the price for swimmers with fit issues, and their 100% leak-free guarantee attempts to ensure customer satisfaction.

Introducing TheMagic5 Swimming Goggles

THEMAGIC5 custom goggle




TheMagic5 swimming goggles are for swimmers who crave a perfect fit (which I think is all of us). They are the first company that uses advanced 3D printing technology to craft each pair of swimming goggles to the exact specifications of your face shape.

The name of the company – TheMagic5 – is for the 5% edge you may get when using their goggles.

Whether you’re a casual swimmer, a dedicated triathlete, or a competitive swimmer who’s had enough of constantly readjusting your goggles mid-race of an Ironman swim, TheMagic5 goggles are designed to meet your needs.

The Magic5 goggles are designed to be leak-proof without the need for the usual suction. The company claims that with their design you can say goodbye to those unsightly goggle marks after your swim. Plus, Jan Frodeno and a ton of other top professional athletes wear these, so they must be good.

Do they live up to the hype? Let’s dive in and put these claims to the test.

Getting Started with TheMagic5 Goggles

Purchasing TheMagic5 Goggles is a new journey itself. You go to TheMagic5 website

Ordering a custom pair of TheMagic5 goggles starts with a few simple steps. The process is straightforward, but it’s unlike any other goggle purchase I’ve made before.

Step 1 – The Purchase Journey

Start by going to TheMagic5 website to shop for your best swimming goggles. The site invites you to choose from an array of lens options, including:

  • Blue mirrored
  • Blue tint
  • Black mirrored
  • Black smoke
  • Pink mirrored
  • Pink gold

You find the color that you like best and purchase it through their online shopping cart. After you complete the purchase, you’ll be presented with an order ID number. This order ID number is what you’ll put into the Magic5 phone app.

Step 2 – Face Scanning and Order Linking

Once I completed my order, I needed to scan my face and then link that data to my order. This is done through the Magic5 phone app.

Here’s how it happens:

  1. Download TheMagic5 app.
  2. Create an account and follow the prompts to scan your face from multiple angles.
  3. The face scan meticulously measures your eye length, size, nose bridge width, eye socket, and facial contours to create a pair of goggles that fits perfectly.
  4. You will put in your order ID number to link your facial data to your order.
  5. Your order is then put into the queue to be custom-created via the robotic process.

Within a couple of days, your custom goggles are sent for production. I began receiving emails every few days that would explain where my order was in the process, along with ways to improve my TheMagic5 experience once I received the goggles.

Step 3 – Delivery

I’m in the middle of the United States, and between submitting my face scan to receiving my goggles took took just over three weeks (23 days total).

This time period was made easier with the consistent email updates, and care instructions for my goggles, which was a nice touch.

TheMagic5 Goggles Unboxing

TheMagic5 goggles case

TheMagic5 goggles comes in its own hard-cover case. Contents of the case are:

  • Your custom goggles
  • 4 additional nosepieces in various sizes
  • Instructions on fit and how to reach customer service
TheMagic5 Goggles in their case

Each new pair is tailored to match your face’s contours, promising a unique wearing experience that stands out in both comfort and style.

TheMagic5 goggles extra nosepieces
4 different nosepieces so you can get the best fit

I quickly adjusted the strap and tried the goggles on.

Comfort and Fit

TheMagic5 Goggles showing no flange on the silicone part
The silicon part of the goggles is straight and relatively thin. There’s no flange, which is unique.

TheMagic5’s soft silicone gaskets are unique, in that they do not have a flange to keep out water. They are built to conform to your face without creating unwanted pressure points or squeezing your eyes—a common issue with traditional goggles. You don’t have to strap the goggles on as tight as other goggles either. They feel good.

TheMagic5 goggles instructions that come with the goggles

The dual straps are long and stretchy, offering ample room for adjustments, even if it means you might need to trim the excess. The straps are pretty thin and provide an easy fit. Adjusting the straps the first time requires a little bit of a struggle, but you know they won’t come loose once you have the right length.

The precision of the custom fit means you can swim with less strap tension, reducing the likelihood of post-swim headaches.

A side-view of TheMagic5 goggles on my face showing how they sit in my eye socket
TheMagic5 Goggles fit “in” the eye socket, which has an aggressive feel to it

I tried different adjustments with different nose pieces, and found that if I went slightly narrower, it seemed to fit the best.

Lens Features

TheMagic5 goggles

The design itself is the result of their technology-driven approach. Their angular diamond-shaped lenses are designed to enhance peripheral vision, allowing you to keep an eye on the competition without turning your head.

The lens sits pretty close to your eyes, but I never felt like my eye lashes were brushing against them at any point.

Real-World Testing of TheMagic5 Goggles

It’s time to test these goggle out and see how they compare to the AquaSpere Kayenne Pro swim goggles I normally wear.

Even with very little pressure, the goggles clung to my face like they were made to be there—no leaks, no fogging, no adjustments needed mid-lap. Even after rigorous flip turns and dives, the goggles stayed put, proving that the face scan technology is more than just a gimmick.

It felt strange to be wearing goggles that fit “inside” my eye socket, as the Kayenne Pro goggles fit outside, which I find very comfortable. It felt like it kept putting slight pressure on the top of my eyeball. Not sure if that is normal or not.

Did I get a 5% edge by wearing these over my normal swimming goggles? That’s hard to say. I may have to use them more to actually determine that. Right now, I”m still getting used to how they fit, which is quite different for me. Time will tell though.

One thing that I think is important to note – These are the only goggles that I’ve ever used where I did not have any eye rings after my swim. No marks at all. I think that is due to the custom fit and less pressure needed to keep them on your face.

I only have the blue magic mirror gold color, which are for mid-sunny days. If I was going to be swimming in open water during very sunny conditions, I’d probably opt for a darker shade, which is available from the Magic5 website.

Pros and Cons

TheMagic5 goggles score high on comfort, but they’re not without their drawbacks. While they start strong with a snug fit and clear vision, for long swims I just couldn’t get totally comfortable with how they sit inside my eye socket. Perhaps this will change over time, since I’ve used the same type of goggles for close to a decade now.

Product Pros

  • Look awesome
  • Very streamlined on face
  • Easy ordering process
  • Quality craftmanship
  • No eye rings after swim

Product Cons

  • Price
  • 3-week lead time
  • Difficult to get used to goggles sitting inside eye socket

TheMagic5 Goggles: Worth the Investment?

I have tried many goggles that sit inside vs over the eye socket. I really want to like them since they offer a more streamlined approach in the water. Ultimately, you’ll go faster when you’re more streamlined, right?

TheMagic5 goggles are the best “inside” goggles that I’ve tried. But I still find them strange feeling, especially during long swims.

TheMagic5 goggles sit at a higher price point than your run-of-the-mill swimming goggles, which generally hover around $30. This begs the question: do they deliver enough to justify the cost?

For me, I think I’d definitely use these in a short-course swim where every second counts. They look awesome, and would easily be marginally faster. But for a long course, I would prioritize comfort over seconds. It’s a personal decision, but having goggles outside the eye socket is just more comfortable for me.

I also tend to purchase new goggles every other month when I’m swimming a lot. $70 is double what I normally pay. There are discounts when you purchase more than one in a bundle, but it still ends up being more than my everyday goggles.

However, I have no problem recommending these to swimmers who are looking for a leak-free, fog-free solution that looks great. Goggles are very personal, so I would say give TheMagic5 goggles at least one try.

From the moment you scan your face to the final lap in the pool, the experience is unique and largely satisfactory.


I reached out to customer service and one of the co-founders replied back to me. He suggested that I loosen the straps a bit because with the custom fit the goggles don’t need as much pressure to be watertight. I did this and voila! It was like a different set of goggles and way more comfortable.

It almost feels too loose, but they work great and don’t leave my eyes with pressure marks. I’m a little embarrassed that it was this easy, but even after 20 years, I’m learning new things. I’m a believer now – these goggles are really quite different from anything else I’ve worn. They are extremely comfortable and look great.

Go get some and let me know what you think!

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Magic 5 worth it?

Yes, the Magic 5 goggles are worth it because they fit perfectly, don’t leak, and don’t leave goggle marks, making them a good investment.

How do TheMagic5 goggles achieve a custom fit?

TheMagic5 goggles achieve a custom fit by using 3D printing technology and a face scan app to create a personalized, leak-free fit based on your facial contours.

Are TheMagic5 goggles suitable for competitive swimming?

Yes, TheMagic5 goggles are suitable for competitive swimming as they are approved by FINA and endorsed by professional athletes.

What if TheMagic5 goggles don’t fit me perfectly?

If TheMagic5 goggles don’t fit perfectly, you can claim a full refund due to their 100% leak-free guarantee.

How long does it take for TheMagic5 goggles to be delivered?

Delivery times for TheMagic5 goggles vary. In the US, it usually takes within a week, and internationally, it can take up to 14 business days, sometimes extending to 3 weeks.

This site contains product affiliate links. We may receive a commission if you make a purchase after clicking on one of these links at no cost to you.

Similar Posts